This week one of the bigs broke ranks and insiders have gone postal.
Harlequin, one of the biggest category romance publishers on the planet, announced a new publishing arm. For a fee that varies by package, a writer can publish a book that Harlequin will distribute. The pay-to-play arm of the company was originally named "Harlequin Horizons." All over the blogosphere, writer's associations went ballistic. RWA, Romance Writers of America, issued a special announcement which basically tossed Harlequin out of the club, decreeing that Harlequin had become a non-eligible publisher and was no longer eligible for RWA-provided conference resources.
Harlequin responded by noting the extent to which its company has supported the RWA and has provided resources to the RWA. However, because of the furor over the whole business, Harlequin took the unfortunate (and rather cowardly) step of saying it would change the name of its pay-to-play arm and that "Harlequin" would not appear in the name of the new division.
Harlequin didn't cancel the new venture and so far as I have been able to determine, RWA hasn't responded to the name change or welcomed Harlequin back into the fold.
The whole debacle shows how terrified traditional bastions of publishing are over the future. Many websites criticized Harlequin by calling it a "vanity press." Vanity press is a prejudicial and demeaning term that carries a boatload of implied criticism. The term basically means - or it used to mean - a place an author pays to be published. It was different from a subsidy press, which is one where the author participates in the costs of publication in any manner. The terms were created or endorsed by associations like RWA to differentiate "real authors" from "fake authors." You're only a real author if you've played their game their way - you queried until you found a "worthy citizen" or agent to sell your work to the Royals in the big publishing castles. Fake authors are allowed to be members of RWA, and fake publishers can associate with the real authors, but they don't get all the benefits. RWA hopes that because it deigns to allow them to belong to the group, the fake authors and fake publishers will see the error of their ways.
RWA endorses or advocates only one path to publication - the sacred path.
...continue reading "Harlequin’s New Horizon"