After Lee DeWyze was crowned American Idol instead of Crystal Bowersox, an amazing thing happened. I finally understood why Adam Lambert lost Idol. It just took me a year to figure it out. Okay, so I'm a little slow. But judging from the goobeldygob of irate stories and reviews that followed the competition, a whole bunch of folks are even slower than me.
I'm slow, but I'm not the slowest. That's always a comfort.
Last year, Adam Lambert was amazing on Idol and he lost. Okay, some of his post-Idol antics made me a wee bit glad that he lost. But still, the thought remained kicking around in my head until this season. How did Adam lose? How could he be that good, that far above the others, and still not win the whole thing?
This season turned out to be deja vu all over again. There were all the others and then there was Mama Sox. Just like last year, the judges would periodically slide in a sly comment about her superiority. Once she was accused of being too certain that she'd win - a charge she protested heartily. On Tuesday her final songs outclassed Lee's so easily that she looked like a sure thing. But then again, so did Adam last year after his final competition performance.
But this year, my feelings were different. This year, I was hoping that Lee would pull it off, and I cheered when he did. Last year I just walked away from the finale bummed. You know what, Simon's last interviews made me think that he'd had the same transformation as little ole' me, little Mrs. Nobody from the Redneck Rivera. (Heck, if I was gonna have something in common with Cowell, couldn't it have been my bank balance?)
That's why it took this year to make me understand last year and to possibly predict next season. Now that I get it, I'll be able to watch the process happen and chart it in my twisted little brain. What is it, you ask?
...continue reading "Idol thoughts: Why Lee Won"